On this page
Why Companies Go Public
Raise capital: Issue new shares, use proceeds for expansion, R&D, acquisitions
Liquidity for founders/investors: Early investors can finally sell shares (no longer illiquid)
Currency for acquisitions: Use stock to buy other companies
Employee compensation: Issue employee stock options
Prestige: Being public signals success and maturity
Regulatory requirements: Some regulatory roles require being public
The IPO Process
1. Preparation (months):
- Hire investment banks (Goldman, JP Morgan, etc.)
- Clean up financials
- File registration statement with SEC
- SEC reviews disclosure documents
2. Roadshow (weeks):
- Management meets with institutional investors
- Gauges demand for shares
- Investment banks set price range
3. Pricing (day before launch):
- Investment banks set exact IPO price
- Usually near high end of price range if demand is strong
4. Trading day:
- Shares begin trading on exchange
- First-day price often differs dramatically from IPO price
IPO Allocation
Investment banks allocate IPO shares primarily to institutional investors (mutual funds, pension funds), not individual retail investors.
Why? Institutions buy larger quantities and have long relationships with banks.
Result: Retail investors often buy on the first day of trading at inflated prices after institutions have already taken shares.
First-Day Returns
IPO first-day returns are often spectacular:
Examples:
- Facebook (2012): IPO $38, opened $42, closed $38.23 (modest)
- Alibaba (2014): IPO $68, closed $93 (+37%)
- Snapchat (2017): IPO $17, closed $24.48 (+44%)
- Airbnb (2020): IPO $68, closed $146.01 (+114%)
- Twitter (2013): IPO $26, closed $44.90 (+73%)
Large first-day pops suggest the IPO was underpriced or institutional investors are optimistic.
Lock-Up Period
Insiders (founders, employees) cannot sell shares for 180 days (typical) after IPO.
Reason: Prevent massive selling that would crash the stock
Effect: After lock-up expiration, insiders often sell
Stock impact: Many stocks decline 10-30% when lock-up expires because insider selling floods the market
Long-Term IPO Performance
Unlike first-day returns, long-term IPO performance is often disappointing:
Research finding: IPOs underperform the market average by 5-10% annually over 5+ years.
Why?
- IPOs are often expensive (high valuation)
- Founders/early investors sell (lock-up expiration)
- Reality doesn't match hype
- Regression to mean (exceptional growth rarely persists)
Historical examples:
- Facebook IPO (2012): Stock crashed 50% in months, eventually recovered
- Twitter IPO (2013): Underperformed S&P 500 for years
- Snapchat IPO (2017): Lost 40%+ over 3 years, eventually recovered
- Lyft IPO (2019): Crashed from $72 to $20, never recovered
IPO Performance Drivers
Successful IPOs: Company executes, grows revenue/earnings
- Example: Amazon IPO (1997): Crashed 75% by 2000, but recovered and became $2 trillion company
Failed IPOs: Company fails to execute
- Example: Pets.com (1999): Went public, collapsed, went bankrupt
- Example: WeWork IPO attempt (2019): Valuations collapsed, never went public
IPO vs. SPAC
IPO: Company goes public directly, subject to SEC scrutiny
SPAC: Company merges with a shell company (SPAC) to go public faster
- Bypass some SEC requirements
- Faster process
- Often lower quality vetting
- Worse long-term performance
Hot IPO Markets
IPO activity spikes when:
- Stock market is booming (2017, 2020-2021)
- Sector is hot (tech in 1999, crypto-related in 2017-2021)
- Easy access to capital
IPO activity crashes when:
- Markets decline
- Recession fears increase
- Capital becomes scarce
Red Flags for IPOs
1. Negative earnings: Company is losing money; IPO revenue funds operations
2. Minimal revenue: Pre-revenue or early-stage companies IPO on growth hype
3. Insider selling: Founders selling huge portions signals concern
4. Accounting changes: Changes in accounting practices right before IPO suggest manipulation
5. Management turnover: Departures of CFO or board members suggest issues
Investment Strategy for IPOs
Avoid first-day buying: First-day prices are often inflated
Wait for lock-up expiration: Stock often declines; better entry points
Wait for reality check: Let the market price the company for 6-12 months
Focus on fundamentals: Revenue growth, path to profitability, competitive moat
Compare to peers: IPO valuation vs. similar public companies
The Bottom Line
IPOs create excitement and opportunities, but long-term returns are often disappointing. First-day pops are common, but they're driven by hype, not fundamentals.
Best strategy: Avoid IPO day, wait for lock-up expiration and initial valuation reset, then evaluate the company on fundamentals before investing.
